home

Attitude
ProFile
Industrial
Interviews
Reviews
Pi Comics
Talkback
Archives
Gallery
212.net

WHITEOUT:MELT
The sequel to the Eisner-nominated series is this month's featured work.

Writer: Greg Rucka
Artist and Letterer: Steve Leiber
four-issue miniseries
published by Oni Press, 1999-2000
$2.95 each

Reviewed by Marc Bryant

 

Many creative works suffer from what is known as the "sophomore jinx." An album, film, book etc. is a hit. The follow up though, is less than stellar, in terms of sales, acclaim for the creator, or both. The term is not an entertainment industry myth, by any means. It happens time and time again, on projects to numerous to mention here. It applies to comics, just as much to any other medium.

"Rucka and Lieber provide an able, engaging sequel"

Thankfully, WHITEOUT: MELT by Greg Rucka and Steve Lieber is not one of these instances. Rucka and Lieber provide an able, engaging sequel, revisiting the life of their protagonist, US Marshall Carrie Stetko. While the first story dealt with a wider supporting cast and focussed on Carrie’s detective work, WHITEOUT: MELT is much more action-packed and sticks with the hero for the duration of the story. Carrie is just as tough and resourceful as she was in the first installment, a ready model for creators in crafting stronger female leads in their own works. The increase in physical action doesn’t hurt the story at all, though. The plot is fast-paced but never trips over its own feet with hurried exposition or wholes in the storyline and is packed with twists and turns that make every page a thrill ride. The dialogue is sharp and economical, a trademark of Rucka’s work, both in comics and his Atticus Kodiak series of novels.
"Artist Steve Lieber continues to deliver just as much as Rucka."

Artist Steve Lieber continues to deliver just as much as Rucka. His panels are rich with what has become a trademark gritty texture that brings Rucka’s scripts to life perfectly. His characters are beautifully human and the harsh environment of Antarctica becomes a character in itself. Lieber’s narrative tone and pacing are top notch as well - the quiet moments simmer and the action scenes explode off of the page.

The only complaints I have here are minor ones. I miss Sharpe, the British intelligence agent from the original WHITEOUT. Hopefully we’ll see her in the spotlight in another installment. Also, I miss the guest covers from Dave Gibbons, Matt Wagner and Mike Mignola from the last series. Still, this latest cover design is bold, and publishers Oni Press are to be commended for a taking a chance with a facet of the medium that has grown pretty stale lately.

Rucka and Lieber have delivered another triumph with WHITEOUT: MELT, proving all the naysayers of sequels wrong, and beating the dreaded sophomore jinx. Bravo, and here’s betting on a hat trick.

Recommended.

 

Marc Bryant is a regular contributor to PopImage.

Back


Attitude | ProFile | Industrial
Interviews | Reviews | Pi Comics
Talkback | Archives | Gallery





 


ProFile:
Greg Rucka

Pi Comics:
Rust

Image Pop: Sean McKeever on remixing

First Impressions

Talkback:
Visit our message boards